- 2018 – Dermont Shea
- 2017 – Dep. Comm NYPD John Miller
- 2016 – None
- 2015 – Lt. Jack Cambria
- 2014 – Lt. Tony Giorgio
- 2013 – John Buquicchiro
- 2012 – Msgr.David Cassato
- 2011 – Chief Joseph Fox
- 2010 – Hon. Peter King
- 2009 – PO. Susan Porcello
- 2008 – None
- 2007 – Sgt. Brian Reilly
- 2006 – Deputy Chief Chaplain FR. Robert J Romano
- 2005 – Chief of Department Joseph J. Esposito / Hon. Mario Biaggi
- 2004 – 1st DepCommissioner George Grasso
- 2003 – Police Commissioner Raymond Kelly